Phinley’s Menu

View Sections
Sharesies
Soups & Salads
Add to any salad: Shrimp 10 | Bacon 5 | Chicken 5 | BBQ Pulled Pork 5 | Salmon 10
Pastas & Stirfrys
Entrées
Sandwiches
Burgers
Summer Seafood
Savour locally sourced seafood from our limited time summer menu. Most items available gluten-free. Please check with your server.
Dogs
Kids / Seniors
Lunch Stuff
Desserts
Breakfast
Breakfast is served Monday through Friday between 8am and 12 noon, and Saturday and Sunday between 8am and 2pm. Substitute gluten-free bread for $2 extra. Hashbrowns are gluten-free.
Ice Cream Shop
    • Sharesies

    • Fried Pickles (DF/V)

      $15.00

      Breaded & fried pickle spear with a side of herb aioli

    • Sweet Potato Poutine (GF)

      $17.00

      Sweet potato waffle fries with cheese curds and gravy, topped with chipotle aioli and green onions

    • Chicken Wings (DF)

      $18.00

      One pound of breaded wings served with your choice of sauce:
      Buffalo | Honey Garlic | Sweet Chili | Fox BBQ | Applewood Smoke | Salt & Pepper

    • Nacho Platter (GF/DFO/V)

      $20.00

      House fried corn tortillas layered with our cheese blend and topped with tomatoes, red onion, bell peppers, corn & jalapeños, and drizzled with our garlic lime aioli and green onions

      Taco beef 5 | Bacon 5 | Pulled pork 5 | Cajun chicken 5 | Extra Cheese 5

    • Garlic Pull Aparts (V)

      $16.00

      Potato scallion bread coated with garlic butter and baked with our cheese blend, smoked bacon and green onions

    • Baked Buffalo Chicken Dip (GFO)

      $16.00

      A loaded dip with chicken, three cheeses, roasted vegetables and fresh herbs. Served with tortilla chips.

    • Baked Cauliflower Bites

      $16.00

      Crispy fried cauliflower bites served with our house Buffalo sauce and drizzled with herb aioli and green onions

    • Gang Platter (DFO)

      $30.00

      Cheese nachos, chicken wings, chicken fingers, fried pickles, Buffalo cauliflower bites, French fries and onion rings with an assortment of sauces and dips

    • Soups & Salads

      Add to any salad: Shrimp 10 | Bacon 5 | Chicken 5 | BBQ Pulled Pork 5 | Salmon 10

    • Creamy Corn Chowder (GF)

      $7 CUP
      $9 BOWL

      Roasted corn, PEI potatoes, smoked bacon, green onion and fresh herbs swimming in a creamy broth. Served with potato roll & butter

    • Fresh Made Soup of the Day (GF)

      $5 CUP
      $7 BOWL

      Please ask your served for today's selection. Served with a potato roll & butter.

    • House Salad (GF/DFO/V)

      $9 SIDE
      $16 FULL

      Mixed greens topped with tomatoes, corn, red onion, bell peppers, cucumbers and mixed cheese.

      Served with your choice of dressing:

      Garlic Ranch   |   Sun-Dried Tomato   |   Balsamic Vinaigrette   |   Poppyseed

    • Caesar Salad (GFO)

      $9 SIDE
      $16 FULL

      Chopped romaine tossed with a creamy garlic dressing and topped with Parmesan, bacon, croutons & lemon.

    • Beet Salad (GF/DFO/V)

      $10 SIDE
      $17 FULL

      House pickled beets nestled atop mixed greens, feta cheese, sun-dried cranberries and toasted almonds. Served with poppyseed dressing.

    • Pastas & Stirfrys

    • Mac & Cheese (V)

      $17.00

      Elbow pasta tossed with our signature cheese sauce, baked with breadcrumbs and topped with green onions. Served with a potato roll & butter.

      Add: Bacon 5 | Shrimp 10 | Pulled Pork 5 | Sliced Sirloin 9 | Pulled Chicken 5 | Taco Beef 5

    • Chicken & Sausage Linguini (DFO)

      $24.00

      Tender pulled chicken & chorizo sausage tossed with roasted red peppers, red onion, corn & spinach in a zesty rosé sauce. Served with potato roll & butter.

    • Steak Linguini

      $24.00

      Tender sliced sirloin tossed with bell peppers, onion and mushrooms in a demi cream sauce and topped with mixed cheese and freshly diced tomatoes. Served with a potato roll & butter.

    • Stir Fry (GF/DF/V)

      $16.00

      Bell peppers, broccoli, onions, mushrooms and carrots tossed with your choice of sauce and served on a bed of white rice.

      Sauce options: Honey Garlic | Sweet Chili | Orange Ginger

      Add: Pulled chicken 5 | Pulled Pork 5 | Shrimp 10 | Sliced Sirloin 9

    • Butter Chicken (GFO)

      $20.00

      Tender pulled chicken with our house blend of spices in a velvety smooth curry sauce. Served with basmati rice and naan bread.

    • Entrées

    • Pan Fried Haddock (GF/DFO)

      $20.00

      7oz Atlantic haddock filet lightly coated and pan-fried with our gluten-free flour. Served with mashed potatoes, fresh vegetables, a potato roll & butter

    • Fish & Chips (GF/DFO)

      $19.00

      7oz Altantic haddock in our signature gluten-free batter. Served with French fries, tartar sauce & lemon wedge

    • Pan-Seared Salmon (GF/DFO)

      $25.00

      Honey sesame glazed pan-seared salmon with rice and chef's vegetables. Served with a potato roll and butter.

    • Roast Turkey Dinner (GFO/DFO)

      $18.00

      Tender, slow roasted turkey, house stuffing, mashed potatoes and chef's vegetables. Served with gluten-free gravy, potato roll & butter

    • Half Chicken Dinner (GF/DFO)

      $24.00

      Slow roasted chicken basted with Fox BBQ sauce with mashed potatoes and fresh vegetables. Served with a potato roll & butter

    • Sandwiches

    • The Three Little Pigs Grilly (GFO/DFO)

      $18.00

      Pulled pork, shaved ham and smoked bacon grilled with cheddar cheese and red pepper jelly between sliced sourdough bread

    • Nashville Fried Chicken Sandwich (GFO)

      $18.00

      Spicy Buffalo soaked fried chicken, dill pickles and coleslaw with chipotle aioli

    • Classic Clubhouse (GFO/DF)

      $18.00

      Fresh roasted turkey, smoked bacon, lettuce and tomato dressed with our herb aoili and piled between toasted sourdough bread

    • Smoked Salmon Wrap (DFO)

      $19.00

      Altantic smoked salmon, lettuce, red onion, herb & garlic cream cheese, and capers dressed with garlic limi aoili

    • Jalapeño Popper Grilly (DFO)

      $17.00

      Herb & garlic cream cheese, pickled jalapeño, sliced tomato and candied jalapeño bacon grilled between sourdough bread

    • Burgers

    • Classic Cheeseburger (GFO)

      $17.00

      Two 3oz island beef patties with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion & pickles, dressed with herb aioli

    • Sailor Jerry (GFO)

      $17.00

      Two 3oz island beef patties with smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, crispy onions, chipotle mayo and our famous Fox BBQ sauce

    • Southern Fried Chicken Burger (GFO)

      $17.00

      Dredged in our own gluten-free breading and topped with lettuce, tomato & mayo

    • Bourbon Street Burger (GFO)

      $20.00

      Two 30z island beef patties topped with cheddar cheese, coleslaw, honey, sweet chili kettle chips and our famous Bourbon Street aoili

    • Vegalicious Burger (GFO/V)

      $17.00

      Gluten-free veggie patty with roasted red pepper, sautéed mushrooms & onions, dressed with our Bourbon Street aioli

    • The Smokin’ Fox (GFO)

      $20.00

      Two 3oz island beef patties topped with jalapeño bacon, cheddar cheese, crispy onions, lettuce, tomato and our famous Fox BBQ sauce

    • Summer Seafood

      Savour locally sourced seafood from our limited time summer menu. Most items available gluten-free. Please check with your server.

    • Firecracker Shrimp

      $16.00

      Lightly breaded shrimp, fried to perfection with creamy Thai sauce and sprinkled with green onions

    • Seafood Chowder

      $18.00

      Lobster, scallops, shrimp, clams, haddock, island potatoes, onions, carrots, and celery in a creamy herbed chowder, served with a potato scallion roll.

    • Fish Tacos (GFO/DFO)

      $18.00

      Fried Atlantic haddock with our roasted tomato salsa, coleslaw, guacamole, lettuce & chipotle aioli. Served with crisp tortillas & salsa

    • PEI Mussels

      $16: Classic
      $17: Pesto
      $18: Chorizo

      One pound of the island's famous blue mussels cooked your way and served with a potato scallion roll

      • Classic: Lemon, onion, carrot, celery, white wine & garlic
      • Pesto: Basil pesto, cream, white wine & lemon
      • Chorizo: Beer, garlic, chorizo, corn, white onion, parsley, creole seasoning, crushed tomato

      **Substitute a gluten-free roll at no charge.

    • Lobster Roll

      $Market

      A true island classic! Lightly mixed lobster meat and shredded lettuce on a buttered roll with choice of side

      **Substitute a gluten-free roll at no charge

    • Fish Burger

      $16.00

      Our signature gluten-free breaded haddock, homemade tartar sauce, lettuce and tomato on a hamburger bun, served with choice of side.

      **Substitute a gluten-free roll at no charge

    • Seafood Sampler

      $45.00

      1pc fried haddock, fried scallops, 2 fish tacos, tartar sauce, lemon wedge, and choice of side

    • Dogs

    • Ball Park

      $18.00

      Our signature foot-long hot dog, bacon, cheddar, mustard and fried onions

    • Backyard BBQ

      $18.00

      A foot-long hot dog with pulled pork, BBQ sauce, cheddar, crispy onions and herb aioli

    • Kids / Seniors

    • Fish & Chips (GF)

      $10.00

      A smaller portion of our gluten-free hand battered haddock served with French fries and a small beverage

    • Grilled Cheese (GFO)

      $10.00
    • Mac & Cheese

      $10.00

      Our in-house mac & cheese is a meal itself! This meal does not come with a side but includes a small beverage.

    • Hamburger Platter (GFO)

      $10.00

      Island beef patty on a burger bun with French fries and a small beverage

    • Chicken Fingers (GF)

      $10.00

      Our chicken fingers are gluten-free and delicious! Served with French fries and a small beverage.

    • Cheese Pizza

      $10.00

      Our cheesy pizza is served with French fries and a small beverage

    • Noodles

      $10.00

      This bowl of noodles comes with your choice of sauce, no side, and a small beverage

      Sauce options:  Tomato | Butter | Alfredo

    • Lunch Stuff

    • Oven Baked Quesadilla (V)

      $15.00

      Roast corn, bell peppers, red onions, tomatoes and mixed cheese folded into a warmed tortilla. Served with crispy tortillas, house salsa and sour cream.

      Add: Pulled Chicken  5  |  Sliced Sirloin  5  |  Taco Beef  5  |  Pulled Pork  5

    • Chicken Fingers (GF)

      $18.00

      Five gluten-free fingers served with French fries and choice of sauce: Fox BBQ  |  Sweet & Sour  |  Plum  |  Honey Mustard  |  Honey Garlic  |  Sweet Chili Thai

    • Fish Tacos (GFO/DFO)

      $18.00

      Fried Atlantic haddock with our roasted tomato salsa, coleslaw, guacamole, lettuce & chipotle aioli. Served with crisp tortillas & salsa

    • Pulled Pork Tacos (GFO/DFO)

      $18.00

      Slow braised BBQ pork shoulder with pico, guacamole, lettuce and garlic lime aioli. Served with crisp tortillas & salsa

    • Beef Tacos (GFO/DFO)

      $18.00

      Seasoned PEI beef with lettuce, mixed cheese, pico and garlic lime aioli. Served with crisp tortillas & salsa

    • Foxy Poutine (DF/GFO)

      $19.00

      French fries with seasoned ground beef, cheese curds, jalapeño bacon and freshly diced tomatoes, coated with gravy, Fox BBQ sauce and crispy onions

    • Phin's Steak & Frites

      $22.00

      Grilled 6oz sirloin with sautéed mushrooms and onions, topped with Fox BBQ sauce and crispy onions. Served with French fries

    • Desserts

    • Carrot Cake (GF)

      $10.00

      This is the best gluten-free carrot cake around. Trust us!

    • Turtle Cheesecake (GF)

      $10.00

      This incredible cheesecake tastes just like "Turtles" Bonus: It's gluten-free. Sorry, it's still not calorie free!

    • Tara's Feature

      $10.00

      Indulge your taste bud with today's divine creation

    • Featured Bread Pudding

      $10.00

      Chef's choice of bread pudding, served with caramel sauce & whipped cream

    • Breakfast

      Breakfast is served Monday through Friday between 8am and 12 noon, and Saturday and Sunday between 8am and 2pm. Substitute gluten-free bread for $2 extra. Hashbrowns are gluten-free.

    • Gluten-Free Pancakes

      $15.00

      Your choice of three traditional, blueberry, or chocolate chip pancakes with syrup and whipped cream, and choice of bacon, ham or sausage.

    • Cinnamon French Toast Bites

      $16.00

      Mini-cinnamon rolls topped with syrup and whipped cream, and choice of bacon, ham or sausage.

    • BLT Sandwich

      $12.00

      Bacon, lettuce and tomato, with cheddar cheese and herb aioli on choice of toast.

      Add hashbrowns for $3

    • Steak & Eggs

      $15.00

      6oz sirloin, two eggs any style, hashbrowns and toast.

    • The OG

      $14.00

      Two eggs any style, choice of bacon, ham or sausage, hashbrowns and toast.

    • Farmers Breakfast

      $17.00

      Two eggs any style, bacon, ham & sausage, hashbrowns and toast.

    • Western Omelette

      $15.00

      Bell peppers, onions, ham and cheddar cheese folded into a three egg omelette, with hashbrowns and toast.

    • Crossroads Breakfast Bowl

      $16.00

      Bacon, ham, sausage, bell peppers, mushrooms, red onions, mixed cheese, two poached eggs, hollandaise sauce, hashbrowns and toast.

    • Breakfast Poutine

      $15.00

      Ham or bacon, gravy, herb aioli, cheese curds, an over-easy fried egg and green onions on a bed of hashbrowns.

    • Eggs Benedict

      $17.00

      Two poached eggs with ham and hollandaise sauce on a toasted English muffin, served with a side of hashbrowns.

    • Breakfast Sides

      Single egg - $2.50

      Order of toast - $2.50

      Bacon, ham or sausage - $4

      Single pancake - $4

      Hashbrowns - $3

      6oz Sirloin - $8

    • Ice Cream Shop

    • Novelty Sundaes

      Funnel Cake Poutine - $6

      • Vanilla soft serve with sugar dusted funnel cake topped with sliced strawberries, chocolate fudge sauce & whipped cream

      Phin's Brownie - $6

      • Chocolate fudge brownie & chocolate soft serve with chocolate fudge sauce, caramel, chopped peanuts & more brownie with whipped cream

      Field of Dreams - $6

      • Vanilla soft serve with housemade mixed berry jam, shortbread crumble & whipped cream

      Cinni Bunz - $6

      • Vanilla soft serve with mini cinni rolls, toffee sauce & whipped cream

      Outrageous Reese - $6

      • Vanilla soft serve with chopped Reese cups, Reese peanut butter sauce, Reese's Pieces & whipped cream

      S'mores Galore - $6

      • Vanilla soft serve with marshmallow sauce, graham crackers, chocolate fudge & whipped cream

      The Avalanche - $9

      • Vanilla or chocolate soft serve with AS MANY TOPPINGS AND SAUCES THAT WILL FIT!!!

      The Belly Buster - $25

      • 20 scoops of your choice with 5 toppings and sauces, whipped cream, sprinkles & cherries11

       

    • Regular Sundaes

      1 Sauce + 2 Toppings

      • Soft Serve Regular - $4.75
      • Soft Serve Large - $5.75
      • Hard Serve Regular - $5.25
      • Hard Serve Large - $6.25
    • Ice Cream

      • Soft Serve Cone/Cup (Reg) - $3.50
      • Soft Serve Cone/Cup (Large) - $4.50
      • Hard Serve Cone/Cup (Reg) - $3.75
      • Add a scoop - $100
      • Waffle Cone - add $1.00
    • Quenchers

      • Polar Dip (Slushie - rotating flavours) - $4.00
      • Iceberg (Polar Dip with soft serve) - $6.00
      • Brain Freeze (Flurry) - $6.50
      • Milkshake - $6.00
        • Chocolate, Strawberry, Vanilla, plus rotating flavours
    • Tasty Treats

      • Ice Cream Sandwich
        • Donut - $5.00
        • Monster Cookie - $4.00
        • Chocolate Chip Cookie - $4.00
      • Banana Split - Soft $6 | Hard $7.50
        • Ice cream with chocolate, strawberry & caramel sauces, banana, chopped peanuts & whipped cream with cherries